All news
Soccer

Carrick's United host Emery's Villa, beaten on their last two Old Trafford visits

Manchester United host Aston Villa at Old Trafford on 8 November in a game Sky Sports calls key for Michael Carrick, and Pacy's model makes Villa the likelier winner at 48.8%.

Manchester United host Aston Villa at Old Trafford on 8 November, a game Sky Sports calls key for Michael Carrick's future. Villa will be without Matty Cash after his fifth booking of the season, per Aston Villa. Pacy's model makes Villa 48.8% to win and United 29.7%.

Where the two sides sit

Manchester United are 17th in Pacy's table snapshot, with seven points from nine games and a goal difference of -5. Aston Villa are 10th on 12 points, with a goal difference of -3. Pacy's team stats show both sides have scored 10 goals.

The recent results are uneven for both. United's latest win came 3-2 at home to Roma in the Champions League on 3 November, but they lost 2-0 at Chelsea on 31 October and 3-0 at home to Bournemouth on 25 October. Villa lost 3-0 at Barcelona in the Champions League on 3 November, drew 1-1 at home to Fulham on 31 October and lost 3-0 at Bournemouth in the Carabao Cup on 28 October.

What Old Trafford shows

Unai Emery said of Old Trafford, per Aston Villa: “We didn't win one match there.” The head-to-head rows in Pacy's data match that. Villa lost 2-0 at Old Trafford on 25 May 2025 and 3-1 there on 15 March 2026.

Across the five meetings in the data, United have won three, Villa one and one ended 0-0. United have scored eight goals to Villa's four. Villa's only win came 2-1 at Villa Park on 21 December 2025.

Carrick and the United camp

Sky Sports reports that United have no interim plan and have not spoken to any other coach. Carrick was given the head coach job on a two-year basis in May, per Sky Sports, and the same outlet reports Villa are close to a new long-term contract with Emery, who had been high on United's list.

Carrick said, per Sky Sports: “We know what we've got to do, and we've got to be focused on bringing success week to week in games.” Sky Sports reports he also called on United to use the moment from that win over Roma.

Who is missing

Aston Villa's team news has Aaron Wan-Bissaka facing a late fitness test after missing five games since mid-October. Emery said, per Aston Villa: “Aaron is close and tomorrow we'll see if he's training normally and feeling good.” Aston Villa also lists Matteo Ruggeri and Amadou Onana as out injured, with Brian Madjo back after missing the Barcelona game.

On United's side, Sky Sports pundit Paul Merson said Carlos Baleba has pulled a hamstring. Merson also noted, per Sky Sports, that Bruno Fernandes was left out against Roma.

The numbers and Pacy's model

Pacy's table snapshot and season team stats for both sides:

TeamTable position (snapshot)PWDLGDPts
Manchester United179144-57
Aston Villa109333-312
TeamGoalsGoals againstAssistsTop performer in Pacy's data
Manchester United10157Bryan Mbeumo, 4 goals, 27 shots
Aston Villa10139Nicolas Jackson, 5 goals, 21 shots

Pacy's model makes Villa the likelier winner at 48.8%, with United on 29.7% and a draw on 21.5%. The predicted score is 1-1, and expected goals are 1.38 for United and 1.75 for Villa. This is an estimate, not a guarantee.

Sources

Questions and answers

Who won Manchester United vs Aston Villa?

Manchester United and Aston Villa drew 4–4 in the English Premier League. The game was played on Sunday, November 8, 2026 at Old Trafford, Manchester.